According to the
Maryland State Department of Education publication Better Thinking
and Learning (1991), teachers who ask “higher-order” questions
promote learning because these types of questions require students to
apply, analyze, synthesize, and evaluate information instead of simply
recalling facts.
A meta-analysis of l8
experiments by Redfield and Rousseau (1981) concluded that the
predominant use of higher-level questions during instruction yielded
positive gains on tests of both factual recall and application of
thinking skills. Similarly, Andre (1979) reviewed research investigating
the effects of having students respond to “higher-level” questions
inserted every few paragraphs in a text. He concluded that such a
procedure facilitates better textbook learning than do fact question
inserts.
In spite of the
obvious educational advantages of emphasizing higher-order questions,
research studies of classrooms conducted by Gall (1970) and Hare and
Pulliam (1980) confirm that only 20 percent of classroom questions posed
by teachers require more than simple factual recall. John Goodlad (1983)
reports that only about one percent of classroom discussion invited
students to give their own opinions and reasoning.